Custom Sizes

This category contains a selection of custom fireplace mantels and surrounds from Agee Woodworks, Mt. Vernon and Kettle Moraine Hardwoods. Typically the surrounds are ordered by specifying the interior width and height and mantel shelves are ordered by specifying length. Additional customization is always possible.

These FIREPLACE MANTEL SHELVES and FIREPLACE SURROUNDS are made from scratch to your specific measurements and are easy to install using basic tools.

Our Featured Custom Made Surround

Williamsburg Arch Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Surround

Hand-crafted with your choice of poplar, red oak or MDF wood, this top selling custom made surround will add a warm touch to any room. Available in unfinished or in 5 different finishes (American Walnut, Cinnamon on Oak, Golden Oak, Rich Cherry, Traditional Mahogany) this mantel adds instant style and life to any room. (See Item Details)

Regular Price: $700.00
On Sale Today: $565.99 (44% off)

Free Shipping! FREE GROUND SHIPPING

Product Matches 1 to 12 of 50 Fireplace Mantels < Prev Next >

Annapolis Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Surround Regular Price: $2,100.00 Our Price: $1,499.99	Benjamin Custom Made Mantel Shelf Regular Price: $274.99 Our Price: $274.99	Boston Custom Made Surround Regular Price: $600.00 Our Price: $439.99
Boxford Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Shelf Regular Price: $350.00 Our Price: $249.99	Centinela Custom Made Surround Regular Price: $425.00 Our Price: $354.99	Concord Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Surround Regular Price: $1,825.00 Our Price: $1,349.99
Cressingham Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Shelf Regular Price: $350.00 Our Price: $249.99	Cumberland Custom Size Surround Regular Price: $475.00 Our Price: $359.99	Deerfield Custom Made Surrround Regular Price: $600.00 Our Price: $439.99
Essex Custom Made Fireplace Mantel Shelf Regular Price: $275.00 Our Price: $199.99	Geoffrey Custom Made Surround Regular Price: $800.00 Our Price: $599.99	Governor Custom Made Surround Regular Price: $475.00 Our Price: $339.99

< Prev Next >

Custom Sizes –
Shelves & Surrounds

Create your own product! It is EASY to customize your own shelf, just pick out a style & input the desired:

1. Length
2. Wood Type
3. Finish

And you are done!

Custom Size Mantels - Custom Size Surrounds

It is FUN to customize your own surround, just pick out a style & input desired:

Interior Width (See B),
Interior Height (See C),
Projection Type (See G),
Wood Type,
Finish,
And Voila – Beauty!

Read what some of our customers have said:

“My husband myself are beyond pleased with our new fireplace surround. It looks wonderful in our living room. I can’t wait for Christmas just so I can hang our stockings from our new mantel!”
- Christine, Jackson MS

“Hey Fireplace Mantels 123 – you did make my ordering as easy as 1, 2, 3! I called customer service and they quickly answered all of my questions and expedited my order so my mantel arrived in no time. Thanks, it looks great.”
- Charles, Quincy, IL